alrighty, it looks like I'll be going with the Silver..
After seeing all the feedback, discussing it with my Wife, and blah blah, Silver will look best. With that said, if the Breyton Race GT was still available, I would be getting that in black all day!
There are a few wheels that look very similar to the Breyton's, but they're all chinese.. At least the Breyton's are German.
Now I'm awaiting confirmation from Tire Rack to check with their team to confirm fitment and whatnot, and hopefully they'll give me a break on the price since I've had issues with the current set-up from them..