Hard to believe that it has been over 6 months since anyone posted on this thread. While the majority of my time is spent shining vehicles, this is a different twist since I finished the workbench top.
Disclaimer: The information is not documented or endorsed by Adam's and following the items is strictly at your own risk. Never use a Pad on alternative objects that you intend to use again on a vehicle. The ones I previously used for headlights make great donors since they are usually abused, yet have plenty of life left in them for alternate uses.
To get the shine I ended up with 10 coats of Spar Urethane, with #0000 steel wood and/or 600 grit sandpaper and a final sanding with 1000 grit. Anyone unfamiliar with Spar Urethane it has good resistance to UV light, can handle big temperature differences and generally does not crack or yellow. The top itself is Birch Butcher Block, 26 inches wide with two 8 foot sections. This was a slow process with a minimum of two days between coats, all actions were by hand.
The polishing was accomplishing with a retired Adams' Headlight Kit using the Blue Pad with Compound, followed by a White pad and One-Stop-Polish and a final once-over with Polish. The last step was to go over it with Adam's Glass Cleaner and an old microfiber to remove all the residue.
One of the things when doing wood and Spar Urethane is to limit the number of passes and don't dwell on any single spot - i.e. keep moving. I still worked 2 foot sections, actually 2 foot by 26 inches, kept it cool in the garage and worked quickly.
I do believe the end result qualifies as shiny and an alternative use for Adam's products.